Showing posts with label historical. Show all posts
Showing posts with label historical. Show all posts

Wednesday, March 30, 2022

A Curious Look at 17th Century Chocolate - Some History and a Recipe

The "Way of Dancing" from La Historia Del
 Mondo Nuovo
1565.  Shows people of the Americas
mixing and drinking chocolate in the bottom right.
John Carter Brown Library, Brown University

Having made “A Chocolate Tart” from a 1737 cookery book, I thought I would give a little of the history leading up to finding such a recipe in an English text from that time.  Unfortunately, due to some family events and travel, I was not able to make a new recipe and so this shall serve as my entry for this week.

Chocolate came relatively late to England, even compared to some other parts of Europe.  It is native to and was first consumed in the Mesoamerican region – what is now the southern parts of Mexico extending through Central America to include parts of Costa Rica. Columbus’ first landfall, late in 1492, was not that far away on the islands of the Bahamas.  Three voyages later, still looking for a way to circumnavigate the globe, he sailed up the eastern Mesoamerican coast. Sponsored and funded by the sovereigns of Spain, Columbus was soon followed by many Spanish ships and soldiers, then not much later by settlers.  The European power, often at war with England, had forcibly taken control and set up numerous settlements in the Americas by the mid-1500s, including many in the chocolate-consuming regions.  In English terms, the drink – what we call chocolate was generally only consumed as such – was associated with Spain and therefore Catholicism.  This helps to explain why it may have been avoided and was certainly rare through the sixteenth and early seventeenth centuries on the Protestant island. 

Probably the first time a general English reader was able to learn about the drink was in 1640 when a short work called “A Curious Treatise of the Nature and Quality of Chocolate” was published.  It was “Written in Spanish by Antonio Colmenero, doctor in physicke and chirurgery. And put into English by Don Diego de Vades-forte.”  It is clear from the text that “chocolate” is the drink and distinct from the “cacao” that is the key component.  That said, the recipe included many other ingredients:

“To every 100 Cacaos…

 [Y]ou must put two cods of the long red Pepper, in the Indian Tongue, Chilparlagua; and in stead of those of the Indies, you may take those of Spaine, which are broadest, and least hot.”

One handfull of Annis-seed Orejuelas, which are otherwise called Vinacaxlidos

Two of the flowers, called Mechasuehil, if the Belly be bound. But in stead of this, in Spaine, we put in sixe Roses of Alexandria beat to Powder

One Cod of Campeche, or Logwood

Two Drams of Cinamon

One Cod of Almons, and Hasle-Nuts, of each one Dozen.

Of white Sugar, halfe a pound

Of Achiote, enough to give it the colour

And if you cannot have those things, which come from the Indies, you may make it with the rest.”

To try to translate this for a modern English-speaking reader, one of the first things to note is that “cod” is synonymous with “pod” – something that contains seeds; so, the author is writing of the whole pepper or nut.  Also, in later instructions the author says all ingredients are dried first, except for the Achiote. Following from that, some of the ingredients are self-explanatory: two dried mild chili peppers, cinnamon, almonds, hazelnuts, and sugar.  For the others I enlisted the help of an article by Marcy Norton called “Tasting Empire: Chocolate and the European Internalization of Mesoamerican Aesthetics.”   “Orejuelas” is a Spanish word for “ears” and Norton believes “Annis-seed Orejuelas” refers to Cymbopetalum penduliflorum – also called “sacred earflower.”  This would give it a spicy licorice-like taste. The “Mechasuehil” flowers are probably “mecaxóchitl” another peppery plant that was added to chocolate. “Campeche or Logwood” is described as tasting “astringent and sweetish” and later, used as a dye for cloth, became a very important trade commodity. “Achiote” or annatto seeds were also used as a dye or as body paint and are still used in local cuisines and as an alternative to food colouring.  It provides a yellow to orangish-red colour and has a slightly nutty, peppery taste.  

What “chocolate” meant in the sixteenth and seventeenth century in the Americas and Europe was, then, something more complex in flavour, even if its drinkers did not add every single one of these ingredients to it.  It was medically prized by some during this period and consistently drunk by select Europeans for that and other reasons.  The first English-born writer to extensively discuss chocolate – Thomas Gage – falls deeply into this category. He explains: “For my self I must say, I used it twelve years constantly, drinking one cup in the morning, another yet before dinner between nine or ten of the clock; another within an hour or two after dinner, and another between four and five in the afternoon; and when I was purposed to sit up late to study, I would take another cup about seven or eight at night, which would keep me waking till about midnight. And if by chance I did neglect any of these accustomed hours, I presently found my stomach fainty.”  This was published in “The English-American, his Travail by sea and Land” (1648); Gage had written it several years after he returned to England from Mesoamerica, where he had served as a Catholic priest.

A photograph I took of the titlepage of a 1677 edition
of The English American, 
owned by philosopher John Locke. 

He also comments on Antonio Colmenero’s recipe above and gives his own adjusted set of additions: “long red Pepper, called Chile…with white Sugar, Cinnamon, Clove, Anniseed, Almonds, Hasellnuts, Orejuela, Bainilla, Sapoyall, Orenge flower water, some Muske, and as much of Achiotte.”  Orejuela is probably the earflower from above; “Bainilla” may be vanilla and “Sapoyall” is mamey sapote – a fruit native to Central America. In both sets of ingredients, there is an interesting mix of American products and those the English would need to import from Southern Europe, the Middle East, and Southeast Asia.   

Gage has much more to say about “chocolatte,” as he calls it, including an anecdote about women poisoning a priest because he would not let them drink it while they were fasting.  That, however, along with how chocolate came to be used in tarts, some seventy or eighty years later, will probably come in subsequent entries.  I would like to try and make a version of those chocolate drinks but I am likely not going to be able to get some of the ingredients or even substitutes this week, so what recipe I am doing next is still up in the air. 


Thursday, February 3, 2022

La Varenne: working with his tart, his language and seeing modern pastry in his book.

This entry is an explanation as to what I did with my last recipe, a Cream-Tart or une Torte a la Cresme de Pastissier, when converting it from the original in Le Pâtissier françois and its English translation The Perfect Cook. This includes recipes for a kind of pastry cream (la cresme de pastissier) and the puff pastry (paste feuilletée) base. I will then add a little more on Le Pâtissier’s author François Pierre La Varenne and specifically some of the modern - or on the way to being modern - pastry elements that show up in the book.

First, a few notes on period and language translation. I have not been able to find images from the Perfect Cook. Therefore, to reference the original recipes, I will be using images, with the text in French, from Le Pâtissier françois and there are some changes in the language since those words were printed.

The first is the long “s” – “ſ” - which is used when writing and printing many languages during the period. It looks kind of like an uncrossed “f” but often extended below the base line of text, like a “g” or a “q.” The long “s” was usually used in the middle of words, in place of the of short “s.”

Another also involved the use of “s” in French. The letter was historically replaced in a number of cases by a circumflex over the vowel that preceded it – seen like over the “e” in a word like “être.” The modern word “pâte”, which is used for pastry would have been spelled “paste.” Paste and pate and pastry – and pasta – thus all come from the same source. Another case in this book is the word modernly spelled in French and sometimes English as “crème” - meaning cream. The Old French word was cresme and this cookery book uses that spelling. It became “crême” as per above and then “crème.”

One final quick note is a symbol, still used today in German, at least: ß – called an eszett. It often represents a double “s”, as in “Preußen” or Prussia. Somewhat logically, it is essentially a long “s” and a short “s” connected. The French often employed it in La Varenne’s time. In our context it shows up sometimes in “pastißier.”

From all that, hopefully, we should be able to read the last phrase in the title of the tart recipe above as: “la cresme de pastissier” or moving at one point to “la crême de pastissier” and even more modernly “la crème de pastissier.” Giving us the name for something slightly different in fancy modern English – “crème patisserie.” One thing that makes it fun is that writers and their printers did not always follow these rules nor was there any kind of universal spelling for things. I will now for ease, try to use the modern English spellings for everything.

On to La Varenne’s recipes and what I did with them.

For the tart itself, I made it almost to the exact specifications he puts forth in the book, while I halved both the cream and the pastry instructions. The base recipe is for “une tourte de mediocre grandeur” - basically a medium tart, which worked out well for me. The only significant ingredient difference in the tart is that I could not find rosewater and it is omitted from the mix and not sprinkled over the top with sugar at the end.

La Varenne, probably because this is the first entry in a chapter, puts a lot of general tips in this recipe, which are useful but need to be sifted through. He talks about when and how to butter your pans for instance and does not get into ingredients until almost a page in. This stretches a fairly simple recipe to almost three and a half pages; these are small pages but still.

One of the first things he says is that you can use either fine paste or leaved paste (de fueilletage). I chose the second, known in modern English as puff pastry. After my past failure with period puff pastry, this turned out pretty well but as I said in my recipe a few days ago, I don’t think it was needed or the right choice for the base of this tart. It was weighed down by the filling and the layering wasted. More on the pastry and its recipe in a bit.

The rest of the ingredients are basically mixed together and include, in translation, “a quarter of a pound of fresh butter... three Eggs of Pastry men's Cream, one good handful of sugar.” He gives no real measurements for the cinnamon, currents, pine nuts, and confit or candied lemon peel so I weighed out what I thought looked good. Maybe for some, there could be less currants. I covered the tart with strips of pastry as he said but I baked it longer than he called for. The recipe says: “un quart d’heure” but going visually by the pastry, I went 25 minutes, not 15, and then sprinkled it with sugar and baked it a bit longer, as he instructed. There are more tips about pastry and currants and pine nuts added at the end.

Whether it was the right pastry for this, the puff pastry - pâte feuilletée - recipe he gave elsewhere in the book worked quite well. The base is just flour, salt and water with the butter added on top of the dough and then layered in with folds. He gives measurements for both the salt and the flour with the water just being “une ver(r)ee” - a glass. I halved the numbers he gives, just going from the fact I knew it was too much flour for one tart and even halved, it still was. The flour measurement took a little work. I did not trust the English translation which called for half a peck, so I went to the French original which called for a “demy-quart.” A French quart – different from an English quart - in the period was apparently about 0.7 Imperial gallons, so I used that to get to litres and then grams.

I followed the physical instructions almost exactly: letting it rest, rolling it out, adding the butter, folding the corners to the middle, rolling out again and repeating. I cheated by chilling things in the fridge at points and I did not heed his instruction to spread the butter initially “avec vos mains.” I sliced the butter and placed it, using my hands as little as I could, as to not melt the butter.

With the relative success and redemption of period puff pastry concluded (moral of the story: trust the French in these matters), I move to my failure and adjustments of period pastry cream. My first attempts looked like a jello-y mass with bits of raw flour in it.


Firstly, I halved the given recipe, since the tart only called for pastry cream that amounted to “environ las grosseur de trois oeufs” - about the size of three eggs. The measurements needed a bit of math again, the French version called for “une chopine” of milk and a “demy-litron” of flour. My efforts in conversion got me to amounts that were pretty similar. This was seemingly backed up by The Perfect Cook’s version which gave a half pint for both the milk and flour. This was strange because in pastry cream recipes today, there is a lot more milk than flour (or other thickener) but I went with it. You boil the milk and then add a mixture of flour and eggs to it, according to La Varenne. When I did this the first time, it instantly solidified without mixing or cooking out the flour and, even after I added butter at the end, I got what you see above.

The second time I reduced the flour substantially, making sure the flour and egg mixture was pourably thin. I added the step of tempering – taking a bit of the hot boiling milk and mixing into the flour and eggs, to try to prevent the eggs from seizing when they hit the pan. It still ended up gloopy but I was able to cook out the flour for a few minutes and when I added the butter and later the other tart ingredients, it worked.

I mentioned earlier that I came not to trust The Perfect Cook’s translation, which was very literal is some cases and off in others. There is an example that leads to my last thoughts for this week on La Varenne. The English translation has instructions “to make a March-Pain wafer.” March-pain or marchpane (and a host of other variants) are what would come to be universally spelled marzipan – a paste based on sugar and almonds. Le Pâtissier françois calls the same recipe “Pain benist” or modernly pain bénit, which is literally translated blessed bread. The recipe in both books is for this bread, which was, and rarely still is, sometimes used as a Catholic sacrament in addition to the Eucharist. There are no almonds in either version; it is not marzipan. This error is important in and of itself – it is the wrong title – but it also shows some of the modern names and dishes that La Varenne is presenting.

François Pierre La Varenne was the cook for the Marquis d'Huxelles in France and his works show one of the first conscious movements from medieval to modern cuisine. I will undoubtably talk more about this fundamental shift in future entries but the general idea was to make things taste like themselves (a cabbage dish should taste like cabbage) with complimentary herbs and a reduction of spices and superfluous ingredients.

The book we have been looking at, Le Pâtissier françois, participates less in that but does show the beginnings of another element of modern cuisine: French pastry. He uses modern terms for things that are slightly different like the pastry cream or for preparations that are somewhat removed from what the word refers to today. He has, for instance a recipe for “feuilletine” which for him is a flavoured pastry cream between two sheets of puff pastry (both historical and presently called pâte feuilletée). Feuilletine is today a dessert of layered crepes. La Varenne’s “tourte de franchipanne” includes something like modern frangipane or almond cream but adds a number of other ingredients. Others are closer: he does have an actual recipe for “Marchpane”, which is almonds and sugar with egg whites and rosewater, like some modern marzipan recipes. Another almond-based modern recipe is one for macarons; small discs are made with the ground nut, sugar and egg whites, they are baked then two are pressed together with a filling. There is no filling included in the period cookery book’s instructions but the base ingredients are the same. As a final example for today, La Varenne has instructions to make “petits choux,” small buns like the choux pastry that are filled today to make creampuffs or profiteroles.

These are not all the important steps towards modern pastry the book contains so I am sure we will revisit Le Pâtissier françois again but I will probably do something savoury for my next entry.

Wednesday, January 12, 2022

Venison from Closets: Some Historical Context for Certain Kind of Pasty

Today I just wanted to add a little historical background on the two recipes that provided the general base for my venison pasty, and on the dish as a whole in the period. 

Title page and frontispiece from the 
firth edition of the work

As I mentioned in the modern adaption entry, one of the recipes I based my version on came from Hannah Woolley’s The Queen-Like Closet. The title is part of an interesting bit of period culture. Woolley’s book went to print in 1670 and is a direct reference to a book published fifteen years earlier. The Queens Closet Opened (1655) purported to be the recipe collection of Queen Henrietta Maria, the wife of Charles I. It was first published after the king’s execution, during the rule of Oliver Cromwell and a huge part of its appeal was the idea of laying bare the royal household. A closet or cabinet was the most private area of a noble, or in this case royal, house; it promised secret and powerful knowledge - a Cabinet in modern politics is an extension of this idea. The housekeeping and cookery book, whether it contained the Queen’s recipes or not, was very popular going through ten printings before the end of the century. Woolley who was generally writing for readers outside the noble class was using this context to help sell her recipes.


Looking at her instructions “To make a Venison Pasty” in The Queen-Like Closet, it is similar to many versions but I picked it partly for its fairly early date and partly for its mostly straightforward instructions. 

The pastry portion of her recipe is much less rich than Charles Carter’s, which I used. She calls for a peck of flour to three (3) lbs of butter and one egg; compare that to the other base recipe which would have eight (8) lbs of butter and 16 eggs for the same amount of flour. She does use cream instead of water to make up her paste. Claret wine is used to make what is called a leer: it is poured into the vent you make in the top of the pastry; that is the only seasoning other than salt and pepper. 


This basic seasoning minus the wine is all that is found in a lot of the period recipes for this dish, including the one in The Compleat City and Country Cook (1732) by Charles Carter. He was a professional cook for a number of nobles according to the preface to his work: he lists a duke, as well as a handful of earls and generals amongst his patrons. He served them abroad in military and diplomatic posts, as well as at their homes in England. An interesting development in cookery books can be seen in later compilations of his recipes. A third edition from 1749 is called The London and Country Cook: Or, Accomplished Housewife; Carter is still first-billed as author but the titlepage also proclaims that it is “revised and much improved by a GENTLEWOMAN; many years housekeeper to an eminent merchant in the City of London.” For me at least, it appears to be a part of the small shift towards female writers, as well as being an example of the fairly new practice of a commercial author writing to a reader when both were not necessarily associated with a noble house. 


The frontispiece from the 3rd edition
with obvious direction to female 
readers



As far as his actual venison pasty goes, the other major difference in his as compared to Woolley’s is his leer: like many other period recipes, he first breaks and boils the bones and pours that into the vent in the pastry. However, he does this after the pastry comes out of the oven. The collagen in the bones would make a jelly that is common in savoury English pies today. 


Overall and once again, it is quite a simple dish for the period and I was surprised at how many authors at least mention it, as well as how many have fairly close variations on it. Similarly, it shows up in quite a few bills of fare included in period cookery books. 


Sir Kenelm Digby was among many other things a diplomat, natural scientist and writer in the first half of the seventeenth century. In his writing, he uses the venison pasty a number of ways and as a reference in other dishes. The Closet of the Eminently Learned Sir Kenelme Digbie Kt. Opened, was published apparently with his son's permission after his death in 1671. In it he tells how to use the bottom of a venison pasty – the crust - like you would bread, usually to thicken dishes. In his general instructions on pottages, he suggest putting “a piece of the bottom of a Venison Pasty” in from the start of the cooking. When telling the reader how “To stew a Rump of Beef” he says: “Then rub it well with Pepper grosly beaten, and salt; just as you would do, to season a Venison pasty.” As part of the recipe “To make an excellent Hare-pye" he instructs the reader to “Set it to bake with houshold-bread, (or in an oven, as a Venison pasty) for eight or ten hours.” The point being that Digby assumed that most people who were cooking in the seventeenth century would be familiar with a venison pasty and to such a point that he does not actually give a recipe for it. 

The famous diarist Samuel Pepys, who wrote regularly for almost ten years beginning in 1660, tells of sharing many venison pasties at parties and gatherings. He was the administrator for the Royal Navy during the reigns of Charles II and James II. He recorded one instance of going to Vice Admiral Sir Minnes’ abode, then names four other members of the nobility and says: “all of us dined on a venison pasty and other good meat.” He usually would rate the pasties he ate over the years as “good” or “bad” but one time, dining at the house of Sir William Penn (the father of the founder of Pennsylvania) he had “a damned venison pasty, that stunk like a devil.” 

May all our venison pasties not stink like sulphur and such. This weekend or possibly early next week I will be trying a fast day recipe from the eighteenth century – Hannah Glasse’s “Peas-Soop.” 
  


Friday, December 31, 2021

Wassail, Battalia Pie and Marrow Pudding: Your Menu for New Year's

 In an effort to present some food for New Year’s Eve, it becomes a bit difficult to separate the elements of cheer into specific days in the festive period. Traditional things eaten and drunk before Christmas were often consumed through New Year’s (sort of, more on that) to the Twelfth Night and Day. We shall see that when we look at a bill of fare for the traditional New Year’s Day.

My above parenthetical caveat comes from the fact that until 1752, the technical and civil New Year was 25 March (Lady’s Day) in England. The Scots were well ahead (or going retro) and changed the celebration to 1 January in 1600. However, this did not prevent there being celebrations on that day during the festive period and, as we shall see, cooks from acknowledging 1 January as a feast day called the New Year.

Returning to the search for things enjoyed on the evening, one - wassail – seems especially important in the celebrations on 31 December. We talked a fair bit about wassail in terms of both Christmas and Twelfth Night but a little more explanation and a maybe dodgy period origin of the term seems in order.


In a book originally from 1656 with the snappy title: Glossographia, or, A dictionary interpreting all such hard words of whatsoever language now used in our refined English tongue comes an entry on “Wassail or Wassale.” Dictionaries weren’t what they are today, there is not much of a definition, though what is there is useful for us: “on Twelf-day at night, or on New-years Eve.” The drink and its role were so well known, the author did not feel he needed to include more, apparently.

However, he does provide an “Origin” by quoting a story from the Anglo-Dutch translator and historian Richard Verstegen who wrote about thirty or forty years earlier:


Lady Rowena and Hengistus or Hengist were semi-legendary figures amongst the Anglo-Saxons that invaded Briton, while King Vortiger or Vortigern, was a military leader, possibly king, of the peoples who were invaded. To summarize, Rowena having been invited to dinner, presented her British host a cup of wine with the phrase Wae Heal Halford Cyning – "Be of good health, Lord King." He did not understand but got a translator to give him the correct response Drink Heal – "Drink health."

The origin is similar to what we have heard before but this time it comes from a legendary royal source. Thomas Blount, the author of Glossographia adds after: “I have also heard another (but less handsome) etymology of this word...because common people do often, wash their throats with Ale, the old Saxon liquor.” As he says, less handsome and almost certainly not true. Whether the drink’s name has roots in British and Anglo-Saxon royalty it is certainly buried deep in the history of the island where they clashed and in its New Year’s celebrations.

Having drunk our wassail – a basic recipe for one type of it is here – we can finish tonight’s thoughts with a bill of fare or menu for New Year’s Day. This comes from the same cook, Robert May, that presented a bill of fare for Christmas that we picked over a bit.


A photo from I took in Wellcome Library in London of 
a later edition of the Accomplist Cook.




Our mince pies are here again and I have explained before a little about many of the dishes and ingredients above. Some I have not included: snites or snipes are a water bird; Battalia pie and Orangado pie are dishes I would like to do at a later date but here are short explanations.

Orangado from the Orangado pie is a preserved or candied Seville orange, suckets from the Tart Royale are similar preserved sweetmeats.

Battalia (or Battaglia) pie’s name comes from the French béatilles which in turn is a diminutive of the Latin beatus. Bible readers will know the beatitudes ie. “Blessed are the...” The French word then means “little blessed things.” In the pie the little blessed things were offal, or the rest of lots of different animals. Robert May’s recipe, for instance, includes lamb-stones, veal sweetbreads, twenty cock's combs and cocks-stones as well as the main meats and artichoke, oysters, pistachios and hard-boiled egg yolks.

That one being a pretty interesting sourcing experience, I turn to one more menu item I can explain a bit - the "Marrow Pudding bak't."  But that explanation will wait until tomorrow as I have some bone marrow and plan to make it a part of my New Year’s bill of fare. Look in for that experience.

Thursday, December 30, 2021

"This kils, not cures charity.": Christmas Fights Against His Rejection

An engraving from the 1653 pamphlet The Vindication
of Christmas
, possibly by also by John Taylor. Christmas 
in the centre is menaced by one and welcomed by another.

A couple days ago, in The Complaint of Christmas, we left the far-travelled titular character just as he arrived in England. John Taylor, the (English) author, has him do a joyful little dance because he has arrived in the “ancient Harbour or heaven of happiness, in the Eden of the Earth, the Paradise of Terrestrial Peace, Plenty and Pleasure, the most fruitful Garden of the rotundious Globe, the comfortable Canaan, that flowest with Milk and Honey.” The holiday personified exclaims: “Thou (O England) hast ever given old Christmas (with his twelve Holy-day Servingmen) good entertainment, with such cheer, hospitality, and welcome, as the Christian world never hath done the like." 

However, things are not as of old and therein lies the real Complaint. English hospitality, even in 1631, is a pale ghost of its former self. Christmas goes to a manor where he has been welcomed in many years past but all he finds there is an “old poor half-starv'd Servingman” bemoaning the present state of the house, “watering every word with a tear.” He greets the potential guest with: 

“Oh Christmas, old reverend Christmas! whither art thou going? What haste art thou now making to this house, where hospitality had once her habitation; where the poor man was relieved, the stranger succored, the traveler refresh'd, and all men bid welcome?" He explains: "This house that from the Conquest hath been famous for Hospitality, is now buried in her own ruins.” 

The culprit is the young master, who is off in the City of London and partaking of all that represents in commercial interests. As I mentioned in an earlier post, it is not new to condemn monetary forces that overwelm other aspects of the festive season. The seventeenth century serving man that Christmas meets gives a number of examples in which foodstuffs (the backbone of the holiday) have been decimated for new concerns.

“Is there a Calf or Sheep in the Pastures? no, they are all knockt on the head, and have their throats cut, having Parchment made of their skin to make him bonds after he had sold their flesh. Look into the Garden, is there a Beehive there? no, all the honey-birds are fled, and the Wax spent in sealing Bonds for Commodities. Look about the Yard, there is not a Ducke, Chicken, Hen or Capon to be seen? not a Goose to be had? they are all pluckt, and have pens made of their quills.” 

The old provider of hospitality concludes: “O Christmas, Christmas, my old eyes are almost bloodshot with weeping at the follies of my young Master, who instead of making his Chimneys smoke in the Country, makes his nose smoke in a Tobacco-shop in the City.” Tobacco was, of course, introduced to England relatively recently at this point, coming from the New World, which was an axis in extensive and often dehumanizing trade efforts. 

Christmas moves about the manor house, seeing just dust where memories of cheering many once were. Once such memory takes a mock military tone: “I have known the time when I have seen a Gentleman Server...that Captainlike led a company of Servingmen armed with full dishes of meat...and spite of hunger and famine place the right worshipful sur-loin at the upper end of the Table, attended by two saucers of Vinegar and Pepper, that waited on him like his Pages. If these stout Captains, Brawn and burly Beef could not take down the stomachs of those that did assault them...instantly upon the Rear would come whole troops of hot soldiers, as Capons, Hens, Lamb, Mutton and Veal to their rescue, and after them whole companies of wild- fowl would come flying to their succor.” 

These are just shadows of the past and Christmas explains: “Thus looking into every corner of the house... but finding no such thing as I expected, upstairs went I...and looking into a withdrawing Chamber I saw the old Mammon himself.” Mammon is from a Hebrew word for money and came to scripturally represent earthly riches as compared to heavenly pursuits - “Instead of a Bible he had a Bond in his hand.” The character is not happy to see Christmas nor hear his exhortation to feed the poor: “This old Penny-father look'd as sour on me, as if I had brought him a Privy-Seal to borrow money of him, or a Subpoena out of the Exchequer for extortion: and in brief told me, that I was an imposture, and only came to entice the people to prodigality and expense: and as for the poor he had nothing to do with them, for he was poor himself."  The Holiday responds “Poor your self..'tis true; for how can you be rich, that never think you have enough.” 

The Complaint criticizes two interrelated groups that work against holiday hospitality, the miserable lover of Mammon but also the prodigals who over celebrated and who entertain in the wrong way. The passage above is clearly attacking the first but introduces the second with Mammon accusing Christmas of enticing wild spending. Taylor has Christmas defend himself by explaining bad hospitality. The season's representation does sound a little hypocritical considering what he says he had enjoyed but they provide some interesting examinations of period food, if at its extremes. He rails against overpreparation, for instance: “Is it not against Nature to see fishes that should swim in the Seas, first swim in wine vinegar, then in wine, being so scorcht, carbonadoed [scored and broiled], sous'd, and so martyred, that when it comes to the Table, a man cannot judge whether it be fish or flesh?” Amongst others he also provides this informative period example: “Is it not against Nature to have Mutton larded with Ambergreece.” Ambergris, in modern spelling, is a very expensive secretion from the intestine of sperm whales. It is used to hold scents in perfumes but was once used as a very intense spice. Christmas summarizes his condemnation of food excess: “to have many of these invented and made dishes come to a Table, do you think it would not make Nature complain? Yes, yes; for all this doth no good to Charity.”

The excess and conspicuous consumption is wrong in itself but who it leaves wanting makes it doubly adverse to the ideal of holiday hospitality. “What cause had your Master to feast all the richest in the Country, and at one sumptuous and sinful supper, to consume more than would relieve a Parish of poor folks a quarter? Is this charity...Is it charity to lard and grease the fat Country Bores, I mean the rich chuffs [stupid fellows] that have enough in their Barnes to relieve themselves and their poor neighbors? This kills, not cures charity.” The perfect form of hospitality, especially during holy days, always comes back to providing for the lower classes. 

It must be said that there is a bright spot for Christmas in his Complaint. He leaves the manor but does find a fine country gentleman at whose home he was first “presented with a cup of brown Ale, seasoned with Cinamon, Nutmegs, and Sugar.” At the meal, he has: “Brawn of their own feeding, Beef of their own killing; we had brave plum broth in bowl-dishes of a quart. The White-loaf ran up and down the Table...the March Beer march'd up and down.” By the fire “lay [a] store of Apples piping hot, expecting a bowl of Ale to cool themselves in” and “[a]t last came in a company of Maids with Wassell, Wassell, jolly Wassell: I tasted of their Cakes, and sup'd of their Bowl: and for my sake, the White-loaf and Cheese were set before them, with Mince-Pies, and other meat.” Christmas was not left wanting and enjoys foods we have come to know from the period. 

Despite experiencing this, the character of the festive season moves back into a warning tone: “Therefore England, beautiful, fruitful, and yet blessed Land, take heed lest thy Gluttony, Pride, and Excess, Covetousness, Bribery, and Extortion, have that Adamantine force to pull down Heavens Judgments on thee...except some of thy fullness have vent toward the poor.” The end of the piece is interesting as Taylor neuters this message slightly; Christmas says: “But as I was going forward with my Admonition, they stop'd my mouth by their entreating me to be their guest for three or four days;” and he ends up residing until Candlemas (early February). 

Tomorrow we will talk a bit about period food and drink for New Year's Eve. 

 

Wednesday, December 29, 2021

Miserable Moneymongers & Mammonists; Intemperate Prodigals: More of Christmas' Complaint.

Engraving from the ballad A Looking-Glass
 for Lascivious Young Men: or, the Prodigal Son SIFTED
, which 
covers similar themes as The Complaint of Christmas

After gaining some English understanding of foreign seventeenth century holiday food from The Complaint of Christmas, and the Teares of Twelfetyde by John Taylor, it would be amiss to not consider the main complaint of the holiday. In other words, what the personified Christmas has to feel aggrieved about. It is actually not that different in many ways from legitimate complaints about Christmas activities we might hear today. There is a worry about and condemnation of economic, what we would call commercial, aspects of the celebrations. These are opposite the true hospitality that is especially vital at the Yuletide season and, in the period, religious and political positions were linked to this ideal. Of course, we will try to look at those ideas manifest in the descriptions of food or lack thereof.

There is a position, slightly more nuanced than - hospitality is good - taken by the Christmas character in this piece. There is a balance to be struck and this is outlined clearly with the three mock dedications that the author gives in Christmas’ voice and uses to preface his work. I mentioned the one yesterday which praised the broadly defined good readers: the rare, and becoming even more rare, practitioners of holiday hospitality. These are again: “the most Right and truly honorable, ...the Rightly approved and deservingly beloved [and the] right Worshipful” to whom Christmas signs off with “Yours in the best friendship.”

He also writes: “To the most mighty, much unworthy honored, and to the Right Rich-worshipped disworshipped, & to the all-too much powerful and respected; the miserable Moneymongers & Mammonists.” In a food context he says to them: “What a shame it is...that all the meat you eat in your own houses is the accursed spawns of oppression, extortion, bribery, and insatiate covetousness.” There is this warning to such people from a present-bringing Christmas: “let me not find it so the next year; for if I do, I will send you such guests as shall never forsake you; as the Dropsy, Gout, collic, the Stone, & the like kind tokens of my just anger, which you shall receive as most worthy & deserved New-years-gifts.”

The final group he addresses are called “the Pro­fuse Sardana­pallitanians, the most famous Infamous Heliogabalonians, the complete company of Cockbrain'd whimsy-pated Gul-Gallants, the intemperate prodigals.” In his attempt to get creative with his insults, Taylor got a bit Dr. Suessian and has seemingly invented some words, making some indecipherable to me, so far. “Heliogabalonians” are followers of Heliogabalus, also called Elagabalus, who was a short-lived Roman emperor known for his excess and lack of traditional piety. “Gul-galants” seem to be silly, stupid or fake gallants but the overall message is relatively simply captured in the last phrase – “intemperate prodigals.” To be prodigal, most famously as the son from the Biblical parable, means to spend freely and wildly. The voice of the season is speaking to those “who entertain old Christmas with Gluttony and E­briety, with the ill gotten expenses of thievery, cheating, unthrifty borrow­ing, unmeasurable exhausting, unmerciful op­pressing, or any unlawful obtai­ning.” The farewell to this group reads: 

"No way your friend, till you mend your manners, 

Christmas."

While food and drink are vital, there is a feast too far, there is also a right way to pay for your holidays and, as we shall see tomorrow, who you entertain is also important to the idea of hospitality. With the table set as such, we will return again to look at some more great insults directed at bad holiday celebrators, strung out like so much holly and ivy by John Taylor’s complaining Christmas.

Tuesday, December 28, 2021

Foreign Food in a 17th Century Christmas Complaint

With Christmas itself past, it seems safe to take a post or two to address its complaints. Some of these can be found in a satirical piece from the first half of the seventeenth century - THE COMPLAINT OF CHRISTMAS AND THE TEARES OF TWELFETYDE By JOHN TAYLOR.

John Taylor was mostly known for his poetry and was well acquainted with the dramatic side of London through his occupation early in life. He was a Thames ferryman and so would bring Shakespeare and the like to and from the theatres, which by law had to be on the south side of the river; businesses, government and populace were generally housed on the north. This influence might be one of the reasons why the language would have been flowery but accessible and it certainly takes a tongue-in-cheek tone through most of this piece. The Complaint of Christmas was published in 1631, and Taylor had been a waterman on and off for some forty years; he had also been a sailor in one of the many campaigns against the Spanish, a travel writer by subscription and head clerk for the thousands-strong guild of boatmen. He had published All the Workes of John Taylor the Water-Poet, the year before, and ended up with over two hundred different works in print.

He had an obvious interest in food: in 1630, the same year as his collected works, he wrote The Great Eater, of Kent, or part of the admirable teeth and stomacks exploits of Nicholas Wood, of Harrisom in the county of Kent and, in 1638, Taylors Feast containing twenty-seven dishes of meat, without bread, drink, meat, fruit, flesh, fish, sauce, salads, or sweet-meats, only a good stomach, &c. Being full of variety and witty mirth. Despite the playfulness and outright mocking tone seen in those and in The Complaint, the overall message in the latter is seemingly quite serious. Well before elements of Christmas were made illegal during the rule of Parliament and Cromwell, Taylor bemoaned the loss of hospitality, often seen in lack of food, during the holidays.

In a parody of period dedications, the author writes to “the small number of Liberal and Charitable Housekeepers of Christendom” saying they have become “as rare as Phenixes, as scar[c]e as black Swans ...and as much to be held in admiration as Snow in July, Strawberries in December, the Sunshine at Midnight, or a blazing Star at Noon.” Even through such dedications, leading into the text of the piece itself, the writer always speaks in the voice of personified Christmas, saying next: “I assure you my brave worthy Benefactors, that I your ancient and yearly Guest (Christmas,) am heartily sorry to see your quondam [former] number so much shrunk.” While this is the general message of the piece, I would like to set that aside for the rest of today’s entry and talk a little about the food Christmas experiences in his travels through parts of the world that are not England.


Possibly drawing on travel writing experience, Taylor has Christmas recount his journeys before arriving in England on the 25th of December. For instance, he begins by saying that in the coldest time of the year, “I, Christmas, according to my old custom of 1600 years standing, visited the world; and like a quick Post, riding upon the wings of full speed, in ten days space I haunted the most Kingdoms and Climates of the Christian world. I was in the stewing-Stoves of Russia, Muscovia, Pollonia, Sweauia [Sweden?], Hungaria, Austria, Bohemia, Germania, and so many other num-cold teeth-gnashing Regions.” He says if he named all the lands he visited: “I should strike the Readers into such a shivering, and endanger their wits and bounties with a perpetual dead palsy or Apoplexy.” (Our weather is frigid presently, so this does not seem out of the range of possibilities.)


But it is the cuisine, not the climate, of these peoples that is our focus. In those places, Christmas was given as “cheer and entertainment... Pilchards, Anchovies, Pickled-Herring, white and red dried Sprats, Neats tongues, Stock fish, hang'd Beefe, Mutton, raw Bacon, Brand-wine, (alias Aqua vitae) Tantablins, dirty Puddings, and Flapdragons sowsd and carowsd with Balderdash”.

A later cartoonish representation of the game
Flapdragon in the "Christmas Eve" entry in
Robert Chamber's The Book of Days 1879 edition

I will break down some of those foods that might be unfamiliar. “Pilchards” is another name for sardines; sardines are often the young versions of that fish. “Sprats” are another fish, often salted. We know neats or beef tongues and “stock fish” is a term I have heard used today for salt cod or the Italian Christmas tradition - baccala. There is a list of various preserved meats and then this “aqua vitae” would probably be brandy that was distilled multiple times, given that it is also called Brand-wine. “Tantablins” seem to be small and maybe fancy tarts or pies but it could also be slang for the insult “tart” or for what we called “cow pies” as kids. This might be related to the next one; I am unsure if he means something specific by “dirty Puddings” but a common period proverb meaning - you will take anything if desperate - was “hungry dogs eat dirty puddings.” “Flapdragons soused and caroused with Balderdash” can be taken in parts. Flap-(or Snap)Dragons was a game played especially on Christmas Eve; guests would snatch burning raisins from a bowl of lit brandy. The “flapdragons” in the phrase would be the raisins, being soused in the alcohol; caroused just meant drink a lot, so probably a poetic way of saying the same thing. This is because “balderdash,” probably before it meant nonsense, meant a, usually unappetizing, mix of wine and beer and other drink. Before moving from the North, the extreme seasoning of many of these dishes is not lost on Christmas, who says of the residents: “the men do naturally sweat salt, and the women doe weep brine.”

He goes into less detail in other regions. In Spain and Italy, the Holiday “was welcomed...with three Alphabets of salads at one meal, but all the meat upon five of their tables would scarce give a zealous Puritan his supper on good Friday.” However, in Rome itself, they “did out-Epicure the Epicure, and made Epicurisme seem sobriety, both in meat, music, perfumes, masques, or anything that might with delight fill the five senses.” In France, Christmas found a “great deal more meat and less sauce, but the most part of the Monsieurs were saucy enough of themselves.” The festive character, being written by an Englishman has little else good to say here but one comment touches close to the general message of the piece. “I observed” he says “that the miserable Country people durst not eat their own Beef or Mutton (except the tripe and offal) for there is a penalty laid upon them if they bring not their best to the Markets, either of Beast or Bird; the Gallant Monsieurs have a prerogative to have all.” He mentions no food in Germany, just gambling, but says “the Low-Countries, or Netherlands, the Dutch States feasted me in state.” Unfortunately, in Amsterdam, he gets nothing as he meets a Puritan there; “I told him my name was Christmas. At the very name of Mass, he leap'd from me like a Squirrell, as nimbly as if he had had neither gut in his belly, or stone in his breech.” Anything like a mass was shunned by the relatively new Protestant movement. Christmas voiced by a Church of England poet has nothing good to say back.

With a few exceptions, Christmas’ travels are not to his taste but what he finds in England is not much better and that will be our topic tomorrow.

Friday, December 24, 2021

Come Bring the Noise: Poetry for Christmas Eating and Service


We continue today with Robert Herrick and some simple messages of holiday food and hospitality.  It being Christmas Eve, I present a few more bits of festive and welcoming poetry, to wish you the best of the season. 

From “Ceremonies for Christmasse” in Hesperides, this time beating Public Enemy to the punch, Herrick writes of more mince pies and plums in pastry: 

Come bring the noise,

My merry, merry boys, 

The Christmas log to the firing;

While my good dame, she   

Bids ye all be free,   

And drink to your heart's desiring.   

... 

Drink now the strong beer,   

Cut the white loaf here,   

The while the meat is a shredding   

For the rare mince-pie   

And the plums standing by,   

To fill the paste that's a kneeding. 


Another about pie, this time probably a  one large like the Yorkshire Christmas Pie I wrote about earlier.  Herrick calls it a ceremony, so maybe this speaks of a solemn duty; it is certainly a different ritual than leaving milk and cookies for Santa.    

From: "Christmasse-Eve, Another Ceremonie." 

Come, guard this night the Christmas pie,   

That the thief, though ne'er so sly,   

With his flesh-hooks don't come nigh   

To catch it.   


Finally, verses written in praise of fulfilling a duty: to share whatever bounty you have with your fellows.  When you are enjoying your Christmas meals, you must also think of others.  

From "A Panegerick to Sir Lewis Pemberton."

To the worn Threshold, Porch, Hall, Parlour, Kitchin, 

The fat-fed smoking Temple, which in 

The wholesome savour of thy mighty Chines 

Invites to supper him who dines, 

Where laden spits, warped with large Ribs of Beef, 

Not represent, but give relief 

To the lank-Stranger, and the sour Swain; 

Where both may feed, and come again. 

… 

But from thy warm-love-hatching gates each may 

Take friendly morsels, and there stay. 


Let us share what we can this Christmas, be it food or knowledge or whatever.   

Thursday, December 23, 2021

Make Your Wassail a Swinger: Carouse with Lambs-wool to Your Guests' Health.

A later engraving of Father Christmas at the wassail bowl. 
By T. Hollis from the early 19th century.
Photographed by the Wellcome Collection.

We will continue looking at edible and quaffable elements in Robert Herrick’s holiday poems, leading into the fundamental moral and political ideal of hospitality. Returning to his “Twelfe night, or King and Queene,” we find that after the plum-filled cake is used to make known the king and queen for the evening, it is used to dip in, or is soused with, drink. Herrick writes:


“Which known, let us make

Joy-sops with the cake,”


“Joy-sops" is just a more poetic way of saying the poetic phrase “sops of joy.” What the cake is being sopped in is interesting. The ultimate goal is “To make the wassail a swinger;” what precedes this are, in other words, instructions to make a great drink.


But let us see those directions or a basic recipe again:

Next crown the bowl full

With gentle lambs-wool;

Add sugar, nutmeg and ginger,

With store of ale too.

And thus ye must do...


The initial royal flourish aside, the only thing a bit different is “lambs-wool.” This is not as strange as it seems; it is a drink, still known some places today, and a period synonym for wassail, in fact. There was a later seventeenth century book called The Academy of Armory, part of which functioned as a kind of dictionary for scienctific pursuits and what we would call today, the trades. 


In the section, “The Names of Several Dish-Meats and Cooks Terms Alphabetically,” between “Umble Pie, is a Pie made of the Intrals of a Deer, as Heart, Liver, &c.” and “Whipt Cream, it is beaten thick with a Whisk, then eaten with Cream and Sugar” is the definition of interest:

“Wassell, is a drink of Ale, toasted Apples, Sugar and Cinnamon mixt. Of some called Lambs-Wool.”

This even more basic recipe has a few minor differences but there are some shared, basic ingredients – sugar, apples and ale.

Why was it called lambswool? (What wassail means we will get to later as well). Some writers think that the fuzzy head on it reminded the drinkers of the small animal’s covering. General Charles Vallancey, a British army surveyor sent to Ireland disagreed. He stayed in Ireland after his service and became a writer on Irish history and customs. In Volume III of his Collectanea de Rebus Hibernicis [Collection of Irish Affairs], published in 1786, he says:


“The first day of November was dedicated to the angel presiding over fruits, seeds, & c. and was therefore named LA MAS UBHAL, that is, the day of the apple fruit, and being pronounced LAMASOOL, the English have corrupted the name to LAMBSWOOL, a name they give to a composition made on this eve, of roasted apples, sugar and ale.”

So, we know from many sources how to make a swinging wassail. Interesting that Robert Herrick was using “swinging” as a positive adjective well before the 60s or even Jazz Age.

The poet recounts the use of this drink in celebration elsewhere in his collection Hesperides. In verses talking about the good old days with a friend, he says they should relive various celebratory times. One instance being:


Then next I’ll cause my hopeful Lad

(If a wild Apple can be had)

To crown the Hearth,

(Lar thus conspiring with our mirth)

Then to infuse

Our browner Ale into the cruse:

Which sweetly spiced, we'll first carouse

Unto the Genius of the house.


A “lar” is a Roman household god or spirit; in the English context it was a fairy-like being which was often a guardian of the hearth and therefore good conspirators in this context. Once the lambswool or wassail is put together, essentially what is a toast is made to the lar: the speaker and his guests “first carouse / Unto the Genius of the house.” When it first came into English from Latin, “genius” meant an attendant household spirit. 

That act also points to another word meaning: any “wassail” is a toast in and of itself. The Middle English predecessor to the word was the phrase wæs hæil - “be in good health.” This in turn came from the Old Norse ves heill with a similar meaning. The proper response to wæs hæil, if you are wondering, is drinkhail - “drink good health.” Important to remember.

While there are still many cocktail recipes online for lambswool, I will be trying a basic kid-friendly one over the next couple days and will report back. Also, tomorrow will be more about Herrick, both food and our more serious obligations for holiday hospitality.




Wednesday, December 22, 2021

More on Baby Cakes, later called Twelfth Night Cakes (this time with Beans and Peas)

 

Robert Herrick from the frontispiece of Hesperides 

Today’s focus is the food in the festive poetry of Robert Herrick, who was, as mentioned yesterday, a follower of Ben Jonson and supporter in writ of Royalist hospitality in the seventeenth century. He went to Cambridge, took orders and was a Church of England vicar for much of his adult life. This position was taken from him by the Puritan-leaning Parliament in 1647, after Royal defeats early in the English Civil War. It was restored to him again by Charles II in 1662. Looking for income in the intervening years he published his poetry under the title Hesperides, or, The Works Both Humane & Divine of Robert Herrick, Esq. in 1648. 

The first bit of Herrick’s holiday food we will look at is one found in the Jonson Masque; it requires a slight correction and further explanation. A Baby Cake was one name for little pastry figures representing the Christ Child. However, with further research, the Baby Cake mentioned by the earlier writer was actually more like the King Cake I compared to those. 

The character Babie Cacke in the royalty-presented Christmas, His Masque is accompanied by an usher who bears a great cake. One detail I failed to go into was the fact the cake came with “a beane and a pease.” This is what it most sounds like, the cake had a bean and a pea (both probably of the harder varieties) within it. 

We can use Herrick to explain what Jonson is referring to. Here is a poem from Hesperides, entitled “Twelfe night, or King and Queene:” 

Now, now the mirth comes 

With the cake full of plums, 

Where Beane's the King of the sport here; 

Beside we must know, 

The Pea also 

Must reveal, as Queene, in the Court here. 


Begin then to choose, 

(This night as ye use) 

Who shall for the present delight here, 

Be a King by the lot, 

And who shall not 

Be Twelfth-day Queene for the night here. 


Which known, let us make 

Joy-sops with the cake; 

And let not a man then be seen here, 

Who unurged will not drink 

To the base from the brink 

A health to the King and the Queene here. 


Next crown the bowl full 

With gentle lambs-wool; 

Adde sugar, nutmeg and ginger, 

With store of ale too; 

And thus ye must doe 

To make the wassail a swinger. 


Give then to the King 

And Queene wassailing; 

And though with ale ye be whet here; 

Yet part ye from hence, 

As free from offence, 

As when ye innocent met here. 

The occasion is the Twelfth Night or Epiphany Eve (5 January) and there is a cake full of plums (probably actually raisins – more on that soon). The bean and a pea hold special places, they will reveal the King and Queen. It is like the still-current practice of King Cake, where a figure of a baby is baked into the cake and whoever gets the piece that holds it is declared king. In this case, the piece with the bean would “cho[o]se” who would “Be a King by the lot,” ie. lottery, while the piece with the pea “must reveal” the queen. I find an interesting parallel with the Princess and the Pea from Hans Christian Andersen but since that comes from a Scandanavian tradition, the connection would need be very far back, maybe before the English split from those peoples.  

In another of his poems, A New Years Gift, Herrick speaks again of this celebratory quasi-ceremony. His gift is a verse that will speak of the joys the season just passed, he writes: 

Of twelfth-tide cakes, of pease and beans, 

Wherewith ye make those merry scenes, 

Whenas ye chuse your king and queen, 

And cry out, Hey for our town green! 

This tradition was, even then, an old and wide spread one. The later seventeenth century writer Aphra Behn, in her short story, “The Court of the King of Bantam” has characters gather on “the Evening o' Twelfth-day, to renew the famous and ancient Solemnity of Chusing King and Queen.” A passage detailing the night reads: “After Supper...then the mighty Cake, Teeming with the Fate of this Extraordinary Personage was brought in, which was then Cut and Consulted, and the Royal Bean and Pea fell to those to whom Sir Philip had design'd 'em.” Finding a bean in a cake was apparently part of an old saying then; one translator of John Calvin has him say in 1587, “they thought themselves to have found wisdom, like as we commonly say in the Proverb, that a man thinks he hath found the Bean in the Cake.” Calvin was French and the porcelain or now plastic baby in King Cake, or Galette des Rois, in the older French tradition, was once a fava bean. 

A British political carton by Isaac Cruikshank from 1797, showing a later version of a Baby Cake called a Twelfth Night Cake. 

There was more than just cake in Herrick’s “Twelfe Night”, including drinkable Lamb’s Wool, and culinary hospitality makes a number of appearances in his other works. More on those markers of Christmas cheer tomorrow.