Showing posts with label venison. Show all posts
Showing posts with label venison. Show all posts

Tuesday, April 26, 2022

To Pot Venison (or To bake Venison to keep six or eight Moneths)



After a number of meatless dishes over the last month and a bit, I decided this week to go with a recipe that is almost all meat. I had some venison roasting cuts in the freezer from hunting season and was looking to cook them fairly simply.  It was originally surprising to me that amongst the very spice-heavy and often elaborate preparations in upper-class Early Modern England, venison was often treated with restraint.  It was the product of protected noble lands and its consumption was an elite social marker.  Maybe for that reason, dishes like the ubiquitous venison pasty, which I attempted earlier, was usually not seasoned beyond salt and pepper.  If the meat itself showed you were rich and had status, maybe you did not need to add a massive variety of expensive, often imported, additives to show off your wealth. 

The venison recipe that I decided to try and recreate does not have much more to it than a pasty.  In fact, the pastry used in it is not even eaten.  One version of it shows up in Hannah Woolley’s The Queen-Like Closet (1670) under the eye-catching title “To bake Venison or Mutton to keep six or eight Moneths.” Reading through it, I realised it was instructions to “pot” the venison – covering it with a seasoned butter mixture which both flavoured and preserved it.  Looking around for other versions in the general period, I came across a comprehensive set of instructions “To pot Venison, or beef” in former royal cook Robert Smith’s Court Cookery: or the Compleat English Cook (1723).

It is a simple recipe in terms of ingredients but there are some interesting processes.  I did need to alter some ratios of the ingredients due to culinary logic and the results of the cook.  I will present my version of the instructions then some explanation of my adaption. 

Recipe

“To Pot Venison…”

Ingredients

  • 750g (about 1 ½ lbs) venison round or any of the cuts from the haunch (UK), in one piece. 
  • 2g (3/4 tsp) nutmeg 
  • 7g (2 tsp) coarse ground pepper
  • 2 large pinches salt 
  • 250g (about ½ lbs) butter, possibly more if you want to actually pot or cover your venison for storage
  • One recipe Hot Water Suet Pastry (recipe below)

Instructions

Preheat your oven to 160°C (320°F).

With the end of a sharp knife, make 3-4 holes in each side of your venison. (See Notes.)

In a small bowl, mix your nutmeg, pepper, and salt.  

With your finger push some of the nutmeg seasoning mixture into each of the holes.  

Rub some more of the same over the surface of the meat. 

Scatter a bit more of the mixture across the bottom of a shallow casserole dish.  Choose a dish about the same size as your piece of venison flattened out. (You may not use all your seasoning mixture, reserve if you want to pot your venison with more butter. Add it to that butter.)

Place venison in the casserole.

Dice or slice butter and scatter over venison.

Roll out pastry to the size of your dish.

Cover the dish with pastry and press the edges to seal. 

Bake in the middle of the oven for 4 hours.

Carefully take from oven, remove pastry and discard (it will be very hard and dry).

Place plastic wrap over the meat and the liquid in the casserole, then press down with as much weight as you safely can. (See Notes for the system I rigged up.) 

Allow to sit and cool completely, ideally overnight.

The butter will be solid but check to see if there is liquid below it.  If so, pour any liquid into a small pan and bring to a low boil.  Cook to reduce until thick and syrupy.  Also scrape all the butter out of the casserole and gently melt.  Mix reduced liquid and melted butter and pour over venison.  Again, allow to cool completely. 

If there is no liquid beyond the butter – mine did not have any - you can just leave the butter in the casserole, enveloping the meat. If you don’t have enough to cover the venison and want to pot it, melt more butter, add a couple pinches of extra seasoning mixture and pour over until fully covered. Allow any added butter to solidify.  

Serve small pieces of venison with some of the butter around it on toasted bread.  You may also add sugar and mustard.   

A bit of venison I took from the casserole and potted
with more butter and seasoning mixture in a canning jar.
 

Hot Water Suet Pastry 

Ingredients

  • 1 cup flour
  • ¼ cup water 
  • 2 tablespoons suet (or any fat) 

Instructions 

Place your flour in a medium bowl and make a well in the centre.

Boil your water with your suet.

Pour water into the well.

Mix first with a wooden spoon and then your hands until you form a dough.

Cover and reserve.

Notes




While the ingredients and method come primarily from Robert Smith and his Court Cookery, I did compare Hannah Woolley’s “To bake Venison or Mutton to keep six or eight Moneths,” as well as “To pot Venison” from The Family Magazine (1741).  Specifically, the optional serving instructions which add sugar and mustard are Woolley’s and it did add an interesting dimension.  Since I was baking the venison under sealed pastry and had no visual indicators, I took an approximate cooking time from The Family Magazine, as it was the only one of the three that provided that information.  I reduced the “five or six hours” to four because I was not cooking a whole haunch, which all three recipes use. 

This reduction was also the basis for my initial attempt to adapt the quantities from Robert Smith’s recipe. I was using one cut from a smaller modern animal and I made the educated guess it was about the same as a third of a whole haunch from a period buck – 750g as opposed to 2kg. The first problem I ran into was the pepper: Smith calls for “three Ounces” but one third of that - 1 oz. - of pepper is a massive amount.  I measured out 7 g and thought that was plenty for the amount of meat I had. That is another one fourth reduced, or one twelfth of the original recipe.  I still did not end up using the mixture I made with that much pepper. Trying to reduce the other seasoning by similar amounts, I used about 2 grams of nutmeg – a whole nutmeg being generously 10g and Smith calls for 2 - and a couple pinches of salt instead of a large handful.  The division by 12, however, did not work for the only other ingredient - butter.  Smith’s instructions call for “three Pounds” and a quarter pound (around 155g) was not enough to cover the venison, which is the point of the period recipes.  I doubled it and it was just enough to pot the meat.  

My venison had been tied for roasting previously, so I did not make holes in the meat, as it says in the period recipe and my adaptation.  I untied it and simply rubbed the seasoning mixture into the natural seams and the lines made by the butcher’s twine.

Cooking times being reduced as I mentioned above, I decided to cook the venison at the low end of what you would cook a meat pie at: 160°C (320°F).  If you are looking for a real slow and low cook, this is probably a little bit high but it gave some nice taste and texture results that I will mention later.  

I say any fat in the pastry recipe because it is just there to make the pastry top workable.  You bake it too long for it to be really edible. 

Above you can see the way I pressed the venison while it cooled. I used a sturdy ceramic pot that fit inside the casserole, topped with an old cutting board, in turned topped with a 25lbs dumbbell.  I am sure there are prettier solutions out there, but it worked really well for me. 

Since the venison is pressed and cooked for a while, it comes apart by hand and can be spread with the butter.  The cooking temperature left some firmer, slightly caramelised edges, and there was a general browned, umami flavour through the casserole.  Cooking in butter also probably helped keep it soft and the pepper and background nutmeg are amazing flavours for it to bathe it. The just slightly gamey flavour of this particular venison (the animal fed in a lot of wheat fields) was enhanced by the pepper but also mellowed out by the nutmeg and butter.

Overall, this was one of the more successful and interesting recipes I have done, despite the ingredients being pretty limited and simple. Venison done right is always a very nice thing but this was certainly better than the pasty I did, which was still good.  


Served with sugar and English mustard powder





Monday, January 24, 2022

Robert May's (sort of) 1660 Turkish Omelette


Robert May produced one of the most extensive and certainly most elaborate cookery books of the seventeenth century in The Accomplisht Cook (1660). He manages to even make some of his egg dishes quite opulent with the use of expensive ingredients like ambergris. This would have been rare but not surprising in upper class circles, at least. It is said that eggs and ambergris was Charles II’s favourite food, but not having the budget or access to the sperm whale secretion, we will skip that recipe for now. Instead, I have adapted for you a set of instructions May presents for an omelette, in this case “according to the Turkish mode,” as well as, one of his recipes for “Eggs in Moonshine.” 

I will start with the omelette as the Eggs in Moonshine is kind of desserty, at least according to our current tastes. Because of time and space, I will share that second recipe tomorrow. The modern recipe will be given, then the historic instructions and some explanation of my choices will follow. 

Recipe for An Omlet, the Sixteenth Way According to the Turkish Mode 

Ingredients 

  • 50g of fatty bacon or pancetta, diced. (Unsmoked would be the most authentic) 
  • A dinner roll or equivalent of bread, cut into short strips. 
  • 100g finely minced venison, pre-cooked as you like. (The period recipe calls for hare or any venison, by which it means any game. Any leftover red meat would work.) 
  • 50g of chestnuts, roasted, peeled and diced fine. (The recipe says you can also use pistachios, almonds, hazelnuts, pine nuts – called pine-apple-kernels or little pieces of bread roasted as you would chestnuts.) 
  • Leaves from a sprig of thyme, minced. 
  • A large sage leaf, minced. 
  • A very small bunch of curly parsley, minced. 
  • A grind of sea salt. 
  • A grind of pepper. 
  • 4 eggs, lightly beaten. 
  • 50g of premade or leftover gravy, warmed. 
  • A generous pinch of nutmeg 
  • Butter for frying 
  • A half a lemon cut into rounds. 

Instructions 

In a large frying pan, on medium heat, cook your bacon until crisp and then set aside in a medium bowl. 

In the same pan, adding a little butter if needed, fry your bread strips until coloured and crisp, then set aside. 


To the bowl with the cooked bacon, add your venison, chestnuts, parsley, thyme and sage. Season with a grind of salt and pepper each. Mix well and set aside. 





Wash your frying pan and return to the heat, turned down to medium low. 

Melt enough butter to cover the bottom of the pan. 

Pour your eggs into the pan and make an omelette: allow to cook until the bottom is just set and then push around the edges with a spatula. Move the pan around so the uncooked egg on top flows into the spaces you have made at the edges. 

Before everything is set, add your venison mixture to one half of your omelette. Fold the other half over but not completely, so as to allow some of the meat to be seen by the diner. Allow to cook a few more seconds to warm your filling. 

With a large spatula or turner, carefully move the omelette to a serving plate. 

Pour gravy over exposed meat. 

Sprinkle over your pinch of nutmeg. 

Squeeze out the end lemon slice and place the rest around the omelette. 

Place fried bread strips around as well. 

Serve. 

Historical and Critical Thoughts 

Robert May includes twenty-one omelette recipes in his section on eggs. The first thing that should be said about this one and most of them is that they are not his own. An omelette in “The Seventeenth manner, being an Omelet according to the Turkish mode” appears in The Perfect Cook which was published in 1656, four years before May’s book. Many of the instructions in this recipe are copied word for word. However, The Perfect Cook is actually a translation of Le Pâtissier françois (1653) by François Pierre La Varenne. The French book's version is called “Aumelette à la Turque.” La Varenne was a ground-breaking writer who first put to print some of the budding fundamentals of modern cookery in Le Cuisinier françois, a few years earlier. An English translation of his first book - called The French Cook, The Perfect Cook and May’s The Accomplisht Cook were all published by a Nathaniel Brooke at the sign of the Angel in Cornhill, London. 

A 1678 edition of The Accomplisht Cook

The frontispiece and titlepage of The Perfect Cook,
translation (uncredited) of Le Pâtissier françois (1653).
Courtesy of the Folger Library online collection.

The frontispiece of the  
Le Pâtissier françois
from the
Bibliothèque nationale de France 


The original French recipe text from 
Le Pâtissier françois

May does act as a bit of an editor for La Varenne’s recipes, both in the original French and as translated in The Perfect Cook. The translation has twenty-five recipes for “Omelets of Eggs, or Pancakes of Herbs,” and May omits and replaces some, sticking to just twenty-one omelettes. The English cook also pares down a number of recipes. 


For instance, as seen in the image above, May ends the recipe printed in his book with the somewhat terse: “Roast-meat is the best for this purpose.” He is referring to the option he puts forth in the middle of the instructions: to use raw meat, which you must fry first. The Perfect Cook explains this in more but somewhat redundant detail: “Moreover, if your Hares flesh, or other Venison be roasted, it is so much the better, and you shall then only need to mince and season it, as it hath been aforesaid, and so proceed to make your Omelet, which when it is half fried or baked, add your said minced meat unto it, and so make up your Omelet. And by default of Venison you may make your said Omelet of any other ordinary meat whatsoever.” 

That and another option May cuts from La Varenne’s translated instructions lead into the choices I made in my modern version. I had leftover venison cooked with a broth in a slow cooker, so I used that for the filling and I poured over the liquid, thickened to gravy, in the finishing stage. The recipe as seen in The Perfect Cook says: “after which pour some Mutton broth upon your said minced meat, or the gravy of some other roast meats,” while May just says “gravy.” My version was probably too thick - in the North American style – as compared to what they had in mind but I enjoy it that way. 

In my venison mixture, I used chestnuts, partially because I had some ready-peeled and roasted left over from Christmas. I chose them over pine nuts and others I had around because, venison and chestnuts are a trusted flavour combination; so, in the end it was both nice and easier. I went slightly off book with some of the rest of that mixture. I salted it as the recipe says but the only spice I used was pepper, the leftover venison had been seasoned before. The period instructions call for a little “fines herbes” in French and “sweet herbs” in English. Today “fine herbs” means chervil, chives, parsley and tarragon but that was not explicitly defined until the beginning of the twentieth century. I went with, again, what I had and what I thought would work: thyme, sage and parsley. 

Both the French and English versions of the recipe are explicit about presenting your omelette so the venison can be seen, which I did at least partially.

The eating of this was quite nice in the end, with the omelette itself fading into the background quite a bit. The venison with the sweetness of the chestnuts and the savoury herbs and gravy was the best and most prominent part. The lemon added brightness, the nutmeg smoothness and maybe the sippets or soldiers or strips of fried bread roll would have been more useful if the gravy was thinner. 

Tomorrow: "Eggs in Moonshine," which is probably not what you think but another that Robert May almost certainly took from somewhere else. 



Wednesday, January 12, 2022

Venison from Closets: Some Historical Context for Certain Kind of Pasty

Today I just wanted to add a little historical background on the two recipes that provided the general base for my venison pasty, and on the dish as a whole in the period. 

Title page and frontispiece from the 
firth edition of the work

As I mentioned in the modern adaption entry, one of the recipes I based my version on came from Hannah Woolley’s The Queen-Like Closet. The title is part of an interesting bit of period culture. Woolley’s book went to print in 1670 and is a direct reference to a book published fifteen years earlier. The Queens Closet Opened (1655) purported to be the recipe collection of Queen Henrietta Maria, the wife of Charles I. It was first published after the king’s execution, during the rule of Oliver Cromwell and a huge part of its appeal was the idea of laying bare the royal household. A closet or cabinet was the most private area of a noble, or in this case royal, house; it promised secret and powerful knowledge - a Cabinet in modern politics is an extension of this idea. The housekeeping and cookery book, whether it contained the Queen’s recipes or not, was very popular going through ten printings before the end of the century. Woolley who was generally writing for readers outside the noble class was using this context to help sell her recipes.


Looking at her instructions “To make a Venison Pasty” in The Queen-Like Closet, it is similar to many versions but I picked it partly for its fairly early date and partly for its mostly straightforward instructions. 

The pastry portion of her recipe is much less rich than Charles Carter’s, which I used. She calls for a peck of flour to three (3) lbs of butter and one egg; compare that to the other base recipe which would have eight (8) lbs of butter and 16 eggs for the same amount of flour. She does use cream instead of water to make up her paste. Claret wine is used to make what is called a leer: it is poured into the vent you make in the top of the pastry; that is the only seasoning other than salt and pepper. 


This basic seasoning minus the wine is all that is found in a lot of the period recipes for this dish, including the one in The Compleat City and Country Cook (1732) by Charles Carter. He was a professional cook for a number of nobles according to the preface to his work: he lists a duke, as well as a handful of earls and generals amongst his patrons. He served them abroad in military and diplomatic posts, as well as at their homes in England. An interesting development in cookery books can be seen in later compilations of his recipes. A third edition from 1749 is called The London and Country Cook: Or, Accomplished Housewife; Carter is still first-billed as author but the titlepage also proclaims that it is “revised and much improved by a GENTLEWOMAN; many years housekeeper to an eminent merchant in the City of London.” For me at least, it appears to be a part of the small shift towards female writers, as well as being an example of the fairly new practice of a commercial author writing to a reader when both were not necessarily associated with a noble house. 


The frontispiece from the 3rd edition
with obvious direction to female 
readers



As far as his actual venison pasty goes, the other major difference in his as compared to Woolley’s is his leer: like many other period recipes, he first breaks and boils the bones and pours that into the vent in the pastry. However, he does this after the pastry comes out of the oven. The collagen in the bones would make a jelly that is common in savoury English pies today. 


Overall and once again, it is quite a simple dish for the period and I was surprised at how many authors at least mention it, as well as how many have fairly close variations on it. Similarly, it shows up in quite a few bills of fare included in period cookery books. 


Sir Kenelm Digby was among many other things a diplomat, natural scientist and writer in the first half of the seventeenth century. In his writing, he uses the venison pasty a number of ways and as a reference in other dishes. The Closet of the Eminently Learned Sir Kenelme Digbie Kt. Opened, was published apparently with his son's permission after his death in 1671. In it he tells how to use the bottom of a venison pasty – the crust - like you would bread, usually to thicken dishes. In his general instructions on pottages, he suggest putting “a piece of the bottom of a Venison Pasty” in from the start of the cooking. When telling the reader how “To stew a Rump of Beef” he says: “Then rub it well with Pepper grosly beaten, and salt; just as you would do, to season a Venison pasty.” As part of the recipe “To make an excellent Hare-pye" he instructs the reader to “Set it to bake with houshold-bread, (or in an oven, as a Venison pasty) for eight or ten hours.” The point being that Digby assumed that most people who were cooking in the seventeenth century would be familiar with a venison pasty and to such a point that he does not actually give a recipe for it. 

The famous diarist Samuel Pepys, who wrote regularly for almost ten years beginning in 1660, tells of sharing many venison pasties at parties and gatherings. He was the administrator for the Royal Navy during the reigns of Charles II and James II. He recorded one instance of going to Vice Admiral Sir Minnes’ abode, then names four other members of the nobility and says: “all of us dined on a venison pasty and other good meat.” He usually would rate the pasties he ate over the years as “good” or “bad” but one time, dining at the house of Sir William Penn (the father of the founder of Pennsylvania) he had “a damned venison pasty, that stunk like a devil.” 

May all our venison pasties not stink like sulphur and such. This weekend or possibly early next week I will be trying a fast day recipe from the eighteenth century – Hannah Glasse’s “Peas-Soop.” 
  


Monday, January 10, 2022

To Make A Venison Pasty: Modern Recipe Adaptation


We have a fair bit of venison that found its way into our freezer after hunting season (big thanks to my in-laws) and I thought I would try a period recipe using it. I was looking for a recipe that was pretty simple and moved a bit away from the highly spiced flavours of the holidays. One problem I thought was that “Christmas flavours” - cinnamon, nutmeg, ginger and the like - are a huge part of the ingredients that were used in medieval high table cooking and survive in early modern recipes. However, that part was a lot easier than I imagined. A relatively ubiquitous offering in cookery from 1600-1800 was a basic venison pasty. 

A pasty today is a smaller (hand-held) pastry crust usually filled with meats and vegetables. It has been especially associated with Cornwall and its miners since at least the mid-nineteenth century. Venison pasties from the period I am interested in are much bigger. To give you an idea, most recipes I found called for between a half peck and a peck of flour. Again, measurements often shifted over time but a peck was a couple gallons. 

I based my attempt on a number of recipes but, in the end, it really combines two. One from the seventeenth century comes from our friend Hannah Woolley and The Queen-Like Closet (1670); I also used one from 1732 found in The Compleat City and Country Cook: or, Accomplish'd Housewife by one Charles Carter. I will give my recipe and critique of it today then write a bit about the period recipes and some historical background in the next couple days. 

What is becoming my usual caveats: 

My instruction will include some things I should have done rather than what I did. Watch for the notes and please excuse my lack of pastry skills. 

This is big again, even though I reduced it considerably – about a quarter of the original recipes. You may have a fair bit of extra pastry depending on how much venison you have. 

Venison Pasty Recipe 

Ingredients

  • Approx. 800g of venison round roast or similar (You could use more venison which would use up more of your pastry) 
  • 1 litre /625g /about 4 cups of flour (I used the volume measurement - litre - to try and convert the period “peck”) 
  • 454g or 1 lbs. of butter plus 50g for the top of your meat. 
  • 2 eggs, beaten 
  • Warm water to make a dough 
  • 115g or ¼ lbs. of suet 
  • 2 Tbsp (30 ml) of red wine vinegar combined with 4 Tbsp of water 
  • Sea salt 
  • Fresh coarse ground pepper 

Instructions 

Preheat your oven to 400°F. 

Pound out your venison roast as flat, even and rectangular as you can. One recipe I saw said to use your rolling pin; a meat tenderizer would also, obviously, work. Season the fleshy, rougher side liberally with salt and course ground pepper. Set aside. 

In a large bowl, break 454g of butter with your fingers into your flour until the mixture reaches a course bread crumb consistency. 


Mix in your beaten eggs. 

Working a very little at a time, add water just until you get the dough to come together. Stir with a fork and then with your hands. As one of my recipes says: “do not mould it too much.” 

On a big well-floured surface and using your pounded-out venison as a rough guide, roll out about ¾ of your pastry to twice the size of your meat, with a generous extra amount on all sides for a crust. You are going to try to seal liquid in, so be careful with your rolling. See Notes. 

Lay your suet across the bottom half of your rolled-out pastry, where you are going to place your meat. See Notes. 

Put the venison, fleshy, seasoned side down, on top of the suet in the bottom half of the pastry. You should have another half uncovered, waiting to be folded over. 

Cut 4 or 5 longs slits in the top of the venison and rub more salt and pepper into these. 

Scatter your additional 50g of butter over the venison. 

Take about half of your reserved pastry, roll it with your hand into a long rope-like shape. It needs to be long enough to form a little wall around your venison. It is there, I presume, to keep liquid in and near the meat, so press it into the pastry bottom you have placed it on. See Notes. 

Fold over the top half of the pastry, covering the venison completely. With your fingers, crimp and tightly seal the open three edges. 

Roll out the pastry you have left and make what decorations you can. Mine were leaves and a tree, if that is not clear. Hannah Wolley says “you must trim it up with several Fancies made in the same Paste.” 

Cut a small vent out of the top middle of your pastry. 

Carefully slide your pasty off your floured rolling surface to a rimmed baking sheet. You might want an extra set of hands for this. 

Pour your water and vinegar mixture into the vent you have made in your pastry. You may need to let it seep in but work as quickly as you can. 

Place pasty on sheet in the middle of the oven for 30 minutes. See Notes. 



Reduce your oven temperature to 300°F. Bake for about 1 hour more or until your venison reaches your desired internal temperature, checking through the vent. 145°F will leave it medium rare. See Notes. 



Allow to rest at least 15 minutes and serve. 

Thoughts 

There were parts of this I really enjoyed. The pastry was very short and when the juices soaked into it, it is really, really good. The meat was nice, though I overcooked mine as I will explain in the Notes. There is a lot of extra fat, the venison needs it though maybe not that much. But overall, a really nice simple dish coming from that era. 

Notes 

I made my pastry a little wet and so had trouble with sticking when I was rolling it out. Therefore, I had a number of problems with holes and leakage. Avoid this. 

I could not find suet in time for this recipe, so I used lard. Carter said to use suet cut into long slices, but Woolley called for more butter in the same place. 

The step of making a rope pastry wall around your venison is one I might be getting wrong. There is something like this going on in almost all the recipes I read but I am not sure I am interpreting them right. One talks about rolling pastry thin to “compass about” your meat. Carter says to “set a Pudding crust round the inside of the pasty.” This is what I came up with and it makes sense to try and keep the liquid close to your meat. 

I think my biggest mistakes came in the baking. Many of the period recipes talk about cooking your pasty for 4 or 5 hours and I did want to go low and slow for the venison. Therefore, I started mine at 300°F. However, checking a half hour in, the fat that was throughout the pasty was rendering out before my crust was at all cooked and sealing anything in. I then turned it up to 400°F for 30 minutes to try and get a cook on the pastry that would help. As per the recipe, I would recommend doing this at the beginning. 

These recipes are also for much bigger pasties and were often about preserving the meat rather than making the crust super edible. I did not really take that into account and I ended up cooking mine for about 2 and a half hours. Even though most of that was at 300°F, it was too long. The meat was okay but dried out a bit, even with all the extra fat around it. 

I had enough pastry left over to make the bottom of a regular modern sweet pie, in addition to my “fancies.” I used Carter’s pastry recipe which I reduced to ¼ of his measurements. It was nice and short and it would be tough to ¾ that again. So, plan on having extra or use a bigger venison roast. My meat was from a doe, so there are certainly bigger cuts out there.