At Christmas time, I tried a full-sized neat (beef) tongue mince pie with a period recipe for puff pastry and the pastry was a pretty resounding failure, though the rest was pretty great. I thought I would try puff pastry again, using a seventeenth century French recipe, instead of an eighteenth century English one. Probably not surprisingly, the pastry was much better, though other parts of the dish were not – most especially the mush that was my first attempt at a crème de pâtissier. I will get to all that in my comments but here, first, is a workable recipe for “a Cream-Tart, according to the Pastrymen’s usual form and manner” (une tourte à la crême de pâtissier) made with period(ish) pastry cream and puff pastry (pâte feuilletée). It comes from comparing the recipes in Le Pâtissier françois (1653) and its often-poor translation The Perfect Cook (1656). Today’s entry is just my modern adjusted recipe; in the coming days, I will present more of my struggles and some history.
Cream-Tart Recipe
Ingredients:
- Puff pastry for a 10-inch tart pan plus decorative strips - about 300g (see period recipe below)
- 1 batch of adapted Pastrymen’s Cream (see recipe below) – the original recipe calls for 3 scoops, each the size of an egg. Also see notes for an even more modern cheat.
- 120g butter
- 50g of sugar plus more for sprinkling
- ½ tsp cinnamon
- 30g currents
- 10g of pine nuts
- 35g of candied lemon peel
Instructions:
Preheat oven to 205°C/400°F.
Melt your butter in a medium saucepan over medium/low heat.
Add your prepared cream, sugar, cinnamon, currents, pine nuts and peel.
Stir vigorously with a wooden spoon to combine.
Remove from heat and set aside.
Roll out 2/3 (200g) of your puff pastry big enough to fit a 10-inch pie or tart pan.
Roll onto your rolling pin. Place on tart pan and roll back off, leaving the pastry. Gently push into the pan.
Trim edges and then aside and cover any excess, along with remaining 100g of pastry.
Poor cream mixture into pastry shell in pan.
Roll out remain puff pastry and cut into strips.
Place strips over cream filling as the period translation says: “separated the one from the other, at a pretty distance.” Pinch at the edges to attach to rim of crust.
Bake in the middle of the oven for approximately 25 minutes until just beginning to colour.
Remove and sprinkle more sugar over the surface of the tart.
Return to the oven for 5 minutes or until a deep golden colour.
Serve warm.
Puff Pastry (called in the period books “leaved pastry” or “pâte feuilletée”)
Ingredients:
- 475g / 3.25cups of flour plus extra for dusting
- 7g of salt
- 1 cup water plus extra if needed.
- 225g / 1cup of butter, chilled.
Instructions:
On a large, clean work surface, make a mound of your flour.
Make a well in the centre of the mound.
Add salt to the well.
A small amount at a time, pour your water into the well and work it into the flour and salt mixture, first using a fork then your hands.
Continue to add water just until you get a smooth, firm dough, adding flour if it gets too sticky.
Form a squarish ball and allow to rest 30 minutes.
Roll pastry out as square as you can, about an inch/2.5cm thick.
Cut or shave thin slices off your butter and cover the centre of your pastry, leaving space at the corners.
Fold the corners to the centre and pinch together seams so that the butter is completely enclosed.
Working carefully, roll out your pastry, with the butter inside, to an inch-thick square again.
Dust your pastry with flour.
Fold the corners to the centre again.
Roll out and fold in another 3 times.
Cover and keep cool until using.
Crème de Pâtissier or a Pastry Cream
Ingredients:
315ml / 1 1/3 cup of whole milk, divided
2 eggs, divided
40g / 4 ½ tbsp of flour
56g / 4 tbsp of butter
Instructions:
Put 250ml of milk in a skillet on medium heat.
Meanwhile beat 1 egg in a medium bowl.
Whisk in your flour.
Whisk in remaining (85ml) milk. You should have a thin batter-like mixture at this point.
Break your second egg into the mixture and whisk to beat egg and combine.
When your milk on the stove just comes to a boil, add a spoonful or 2 of it to your egg/flour mixture. Whisk to temper.
Reduce heat to low.
Add the egg mixture, a little at a time to the milk on the stove. Stir constantly until combined.
Add your butter and again stir well to combine.
Allow to cook on low heat for about five minutes. The mixture will thicken and even congeal, this will work itself out baking in the tart.
Set aside.
Notes:
If you can find store-bought crème pâtissier, you could use 3 heaping tablespoons of it in place of the tricky period pastry cream. However, the seventeenth century version does not have sugar or vanilla which most modern crème pat does. If using omit the sugar from the tart recipe itself but save some for sprinkling.
You will probably have extra puff pastry left over from the above recipe
I will save most of my failures/adjustments for tomorrow’s entry but I was generally pleased with the lamination and taste of this puff pastry and, in the end, the filling has a really nice flavour and decent texture. The pine nuts and lemon peel added things beyond just sweet and the savoury notes were welcomed. In hindsight, you probably don’t need or want puff pastry as the base of this tart as it gets a little dense but it was very nice on the top.